Archive/ The Vault/The Benin Bronzes
The Vault · Relics & Sacred Objects
The Benin Bronzes: The King's Ancestors, Taken and Returned
In the archive
- Held
- Dispersed since 1897: British Museum, Berlin, and more than 130 other institutions; returns to Nigeria under way since 2022
- Date evidence
- Cast c. 13th–19th century; the palace plaques mostly 16th–17th century
- Era
- Era VIII · The Early Modern
- In the archive
- African Traditional Religion
In February 1897, a British force of about 1,200 men under Admiral Harry Rawson marched on Benin City, capital of the kingdom of Benin in what is now southern Nigeria (not the modern Republic of Benin). The attack followed the killing, in January, of a British party that had tried to reach the city during a sacred royal festival. The city was taken and burned, and the Oba, Ovonramwen, was sent into exile. From the royal palace and its altars the soldiers carried away thousands of objects in brass, ivory and wood. They were auctioned to pay for the expedition and scattered to museums across Europe and North America. The world came to know them as the Benin Bronzes.
The bronzes through time
From the royal guild of casters to the return.
- 13th–15th c. The casting guild: The Igun Eronmwon, the Oba's guild of brass casters, works by the lost-wax method; tradition traces the craft to the reign of Oba Oguola.
- 16th–17th c. The palace plaques: Hundreds of brass plaques clad the palace pillars, showing the Oba, chiefs, warriors, rituals and Portuguese traders, whose brass manillas supplied much of the metal.
- Each reign Ancestral altars: Commemorative heads of past Obas are set on royal altars with carved ivory tusks, the centre of the kingdom's ancestor rites.
- 1897 The punitive expedition: After a British party is killed, a force of about 1,200 takes Benin City, burns it, exiles Oba Ovonramwen and carries off thousands of objects.
- 1897 on Sold and scattered: The objects are auctioned to cover costs and enter museums across Europe and America.
- 2022 Returns begin: Germany signs a joint declaration with Nigeria and hands over the first bronzes; London's Horniman Museum transfers ownership of 72 objects.
- 2023 The Oba's ownership: A Nigerian presidential declaration recognises the Oba of Benin as owner of returned objects, prompting debate over where they will be kept.
Study the object
Images belong to the many holding institutions; the Digital Benin project gathers records of the dispersed collection.
The holding institution's own viewers
Paste any IIIF manifest into the viewer to study published images; it needs JavaScript.
What they are
- Commemorative heads of past Obas and Queen Mothers, placed on the ancestral altars of the palace, often holding a carved ivory tusk.
- Hundreds of rectangular plaques that once clad the palace pillars, showing the Oba, chiefs, warriors, musicians, rituals and Portuguese traders. Most date from the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.
- Figures, bells, altar pieces, and carved ivory, including the famous ivory mask of Queen Mother Idia, adopted as the emblem of FESTAC 77, the 1977 Festival of Black and African Arts and Culture in Lagos.
- Most are of brass or bronze, cast by the lost-wax method by the royal guild of casters, the Igun Eronmwon, which still works in Benin City today.
- Much of the metal came from brass bracelets, manillas, brought by European traders. A 2023 chemical study traced many manillas to the Rhineland in Germany.
Where they are
The Digital Benin project (2022) recorded more than 5,000 objects in more than 130 institutions in 20 countries. The largest holding, about 900 objects, is in the British Museum, which is forbidden by law from permanently giving up objects in its collection.
The return
The interactive timeline above follows the objects' history. From 2021 several institutions agreed to return them:
- Germany and Nigeria signed a joint declaration in July 2022, and German museums transferred ownership of more than 1,000 objects; the first 22 were handed over in December 2022.
- The Horniman Museum in London transferred ownership of 72 objects in 2022; the Smithsonian returned 29 the same year.
- In March 2023 a Nigerian presidential declaration recognised the Oba of Benin as the owner of returned objects. This led to debate, including in Germany, about where and how they would be displayed, and between the Oba's palace and plans for a new museum in Benin City.
Symbology and sacred encoding
The Oba between worlds. The Oba was a sacred king, the link between the living and the royal ancestors. Heads on the altars honoured past kings and were the focus of ritual; they were not simply portraits. The head (uhunmwun) was the seat of a person's destiny and judgement.
Mudfish and leopards. The Oba is often shown with legs in the form of mudfish, creatures that live in water and on land, linking him with Olokun, god of the sea and wealth. Leopards were royal animals, symbols of the Oba's power over the wild.
Coral. The Oba's regalia of coral beads, shown on the heads and figures, carried spiritual power and were renewed in ritual.
Connections
African Traditional Religion (ch33) and Sacred Kingship (ch49). Compare the Kebra Nagast (V66), another African royal treasure taken by a British expedition, and the Ishtar Gate (V52) for debates about where sacred objects should be.
What's well supported by the evidence
- Thousands of brass, ivory and wooden objects made for the court and ancestral altars of the kingdom of Benin, and looted by British forces in 1897.
- Their dispersal to museums worldwide and the returns that began in 2022.
What is not supported
- The once-common European claim that the bronzes could not have been made by Africans. They were made by the kingdom's own guild, which still exists.
What's genuinely open
- The dating of many individual pieces and the early history of casting in Benin.
- Where returned objects will be kept, and how restitution will proceed for institutions such as the British Museum.
Sources
The objects and the expedition
- "Benin Bronzes", https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benin_Bronzes
- Digital Benin, https://digitalbenin.org/
- British Museum, "Benin Bronzes", https://www.britishmuseum.org/about-us/british-museum-story/contested-objects-collection/benin-bronzes
- D. Hicks, The Brutish Museums (Pluto Press, 2020)
Returns
- German Federal Foreign Office, "Joint declaration on the return of Benin Bronzes" (2022), https://www.auswaertiges-amt.de/en
- Horniman Museum, "Returning Benin objects", https://www.horniman.ac.uk/story/benin-objects-returned-to-nigeria/
- The Art Newspaper, reports on the Nigerian presidential declaration (2023), https://www.theartnewspaper.com/
Metal
- T. Skowronek et al., "German brass for Benin Bronzes: Geochemical analysis insights into the early Atlantic trade", PLOS ONE (2023), https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0283415
From The Divine Archives · https://getconexto.com/vault/benin-bronzes.html